Spending on lawyers
John Jacobson made this Official Information request to Queenstown-Lakes District Council
The request was successful.
From: John Jacobson
Dear Queenstown-Lakes District Council,
This is a request under section 10 of the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act 1987.
Please provide the names of the law firms (or sole practitioners) and the total amount of money the Council has spent with each law firm (or sole practitioner) it has procured services or advice from, and the town or city where that firm (or practitioner) is located:
(a) for the most recent financial year of the Council, and
(b) for the 2011-2012 financial year.
If you consider that one of the reasons in section 7(2) of the Act may provide a reason for refusing this request, I urge you consider the strong public interest in the Council being accountable for the spending of public money, and the accountability purpose of the Act, as described in section 4(a)(ii).
If anything about this request is unclear, or you consider the request may be refused under section 17(f) of the Act, please contact me via the address from which this request was sent.
Yours faithfully,
John Jacobson
Queenstown-Lakes District Council
Thank you for your e-mail. Your request will be forwarded to the
appropriate staff member or contractor to action.
Should your enquiry be urgent, please feel free to phone Queenstown 03
441-0499 or Wanaka 03 443-0024.
Kind regards,
The QLDC Customer Services Team
From: Barbara East
Queenstown-Lakes District Council
Dear John
Your request for information will be processed under the Local Government
Official Information and Meetings Act 1987 and you will receive a decision
on your request within 20 working days.
Regards
Barbara
From: QLDC Services [mailto:[email address]]
Sent: Tuesday, 19 August 2014 8:30 AM
Subject: FW: Official Information Act request - Spending on lawyers
[#1054CJ]
show quoted sections
From: Barbara East
Queenstown-Lakes District Council
Dear John
Please find below the table detailing the law firms Council has procured
services or advice from for the 2011/2012 year and the most recent
financial year.
The reference to “Other” refers to multiple smaller payments that have
been made to other lawyers.
For clarification purposes, it needs to be explained that in the 2011/2012
year, Council was operating under a different structure to the 2013/2014
year. At that time, Council had 2 Council Controlled Organisations but
these were integrated with Council as of 1 July 2013. As the CCOs
operated independently, the figures under the 2011/2012 year column below
do not include any legal expenses incurred by these companies.
QLDC Legal Expenses 2011/2012 Year 2013/2014 Year
BY Law Firm
MacTodd (Queenstown) 805,160.74 510,521.25
Simpson Grierson (Auckland) 154,531.00 128,551.00
Heaney & Co (Auckland) 145,048.00 385,240.00
Other 41,689.53 68,395.40
Meredith Connell (Auckland) 83,517.00
Quigg Partners (Wellington) 42,657.00
$1,146,429.27 $1,218,881.65
By Main Type
Planning Advice 715,722.52 560,617.00
Weather Tightness 155,186.43 385,240.00
Human Resources 1,580.00 47,157.00
Regulatory 108,854.09 32,368.58
Other (Property, Regulatory etc) 165,086.23 193,499.07
$1,146,429.27 $1,218,881.65
Regards
Barbara
Barbara East | Records Advisor
Queenstown Lakes District Council
[2][IMG]
DD: +64 3 450 0314 | P: +64 3 441 0499 | M: +64 27 355 2431
E: [1][email address]
show quoted sections
From: John Jacobson
Dear Barbara,
Thank you for your response to my request - especially for getting it to me sooner than the maximum permitted time.
I am also grateful for the Council providing its response in the text of the email, rather than by attached PDF document. Unfortunately, the formatting has got slightly mixed up, and so I am not clear whether the spending indicated for Meredith Connell and Quigg Partners refers to the 2011/12 year or the 2013/14 year. If you could clarify this for me I would be grateful.
Finally, if it is possible to easily provide me with the figures for legal spending by the two Council Controlled Organisations for 2011/12 (broken down in the same manner as the information already provided), please could you do so. Alternatively, I will make a separate request for that information.
Yours sincerely,
John Jacobson
From: Barbara East
Queenstown-Lakes District Council
Hi John
Can you see the snippet below clearly?
I will ask our Finance team if the further information you have requested
is available.
Regards
Barbara
show quoted sections
From: John Jacobson
Hi Barbara,
I'm afraid I could not. If you visit the web page where I'm reading the Council's response, you'll be able to see the problems with the formatting that mean I'm unable to work out when the Meredith Connell and Quigg Partners spending occurred:
https://fyi.org.nz/request/1916-spending...
Maybe in this instance it would be easier if you included all the information sought about the spending in the two (financial) years in a Word or Excel document attached to your email reply?
Many thanks for your help with this,
John Jacobson
From: Barbara East
Queenstown-Lakes District Council
Hi John
Third time lucky! Do let me know if there are any issues with the attached information.
Regards
Barbara
show quoted sections
From: John Jacobson
Hi Barbara,
Thank you for your additional assistance - I can access the document, and it provides the information I was seeking. I will make a separate request for the information about the spending of the two CCOs.
Yours sincerely,
John Jacobson
Things to do with this request
- Add an annotation (to help the requester or others)
- Download a zip file of all correspondence