Analysis of investment return from biotech/gene editing tech between 2000-2020?
J Bruning made this Official Information request to New Zealand Productivity Commission
The request was successful.
From: J Bruning
Dear New Zealand Productivity Commission,
This is an Official Information Act request, please can you supply the following information received and/or produced by the Productivity Commissioner’s office:
1) All reports and documents held by the Productivity Commission detailing public sector investment in synthetic biology/biotechnology/gene editing/genetic modification and/or the returns on investment by individual New Zealand Crown Research Institutions.
2) All reports and documents held by the Productivity Commission detailing investment and/or return on investment to the public sector from synthetic biology/biotechnology/gene editing/genetic modification.
3) All reports and documents analysing and assessing environmental risk to New Zealand environment and agriculture from synthetic biology/biotechnology/gene editing/genetic modification. This risk could occur:
a) As a consequence of altered regulation;
b) Over the longer term (i.e., it involves long term stewardship considerations)
c) Following release into the environment;
d) Through genetic alteration of native flora or fauna (this includes laboratory based effects including unintended insertion of foreign dna; and includes through unintended events such as via pollination);
e) As an adverse impact to domestic and export industries (including via offshore detection; and non-tariff barriers) following contamination from released organisms in New Zealand food export product to organic and non-organic product.
Thank you,
Kind regards
Jodie Bruning.
From: Shelley Catlin
New Zealand Productivity Commission
Good afternoon
Thank you for your 9 May 2022 email request for information under the
Official Information Act 1982. You requested information on the
following:
1. All reports and documents held by the Productivity Commission
detailing public sector investment in synthetic
biology/biotechnology/gene editing/genetic modification and/or the
returns on investment by individual New Zealand Crown Research
Institutions.
2. All reports and documents held by the Productivity Commission
detailing public sector investment in synthetic
biology/biotechnology/gene editing/genetic modification and/or the
returns on investment by individual New Zealand Crown Research
Institutions.
3. All reports and documents analysing and assessing environmental risk
to New Zealand environment and agriculture from synthetic
biology/biotechnology/gene editing/genetic modification. This risk
could occur:
a) As a consequence of altered regulation;
b) Over the longer term (i.e., it involves long term stewardship
considerations)
c) Following release into the environment;
d) Through genetic alteration of native flora or fauna (this includes
laboratory based effects including unintended insertion of foreign
dna; and includes through unintended events such as via pollination);
e) As an adverse impact to domestic and export industries (including
via offshore detection; and non-tariff barriers) following
contamination from released organisms in New Zealand food export
product to organic and non-organic product
Response from the New Zealand Productivity Commission:
The Productivity Commission has no documents detailing, analysing or
assessing returns or environment (or other) risks relating to genetic
modification (GM). To date, we have not done any work on this topic,
instead we have looked at reports that have been written by others about
the current GM regulations and their benefits and costs considering the
current state of knowledge about GM. Our conclusions from our
investigations are available in section 10.4 of our final report on
"Frontier Firms: Reaching for the Frontier" available at
[1]https://www.productivity.govt.nz/inquiri...
You have the right to seek an investigation and review by the Ombudsman
regarding the Commission’s response. Information on how to make a
complaint is available
at [2]www.ombudsman.parliament.nz or freephone 0800 802 602. If you wish
to discuss our response with us, please feel free to contact me at the
details below.
Yours sincerely
Shelley Catlin
show quoted sections
Things to do with this request
- Add an annotation (to help the requester or others)
- Download a zip file of all correspondence